top of page

Fr. Hugon on the 5 ways

Oct 13
13 min read

The five proofs

These arguments are of universal scope and hold for all the beings that we discover in this world, inorganic or organic, plants, animals, men and angels. The first proof is drawn from the movement or passivity of creatures; the second, from their activity or causality; the third, from their essence or their character of contingency, which makes them indifferent to being or not being; the fourth, from the degrees of perfection; the fifth, from the order of the universe. Although they complete one another mutually, each of them, if well understood, suffices by itself and efficaciously demonstrates the existence of God. All five are a posteriori, having experience as their point of departure, resting on the data that our sensible world furnishes us, ascending from effects to the cause.

The first proof: movement

The first starts from the most manifest fact, one that each of us has observed: movement. That there is movement in this world is a certainty of experience. Now the first principle of this movement can only be an immovable mover. There exists, then, an immovable mover, or a being by itself, author of all the rest, whom we call God. Movement is understood here of every mutation or of every passage from potency to act. It is manifest that beings are subject to manifold mutations: some according to substance, which is born, dies or is corrupted; others according to quantity, in which we observe increase or diminution; others according to quality, which is altered or perfected; others according to place, which they acquire or abandon; others at least according to operation, which begins, continues and ends. These beings are not the adequate principle of their movement. Whatever is moved is moved by another. Now in the series of essentially ordered movers, one cannot proceed to infinity, but one must come to a first immovable mover. Therefore the first principle of movement is the first immovable mover, whom we call God. The first axiom: whatever is moved is moved by another. Let us explain and justify our two axioms. Although a thing may move according to one part and be moved according to another part, it is never true that what is moved is the first and total principle of its movement: the organs are moved by the brain, the brain received movement from the power that engendered the living thing, and he who engendered received it from another.

“For Saint Thomas, the truth of this proposition: everything that is moved requires a mover that is not itself, rests almost immediately on the principle of contradiction. That is to say that it resolves itself into evidence, being evident of itself. What is it, indeed, to be moved? It is, to keep the word of Aristotle and Saint Thomas, ‘to be in potency,’ it is ‘to be acted upon,’ it is in some way not to be. Now ‘to move’ is precisely the contrary: it is to be, it is ‘to act,’ it is ‘to be in act.’ But to act and to be acted upon, to be and not to be, will forever be ‘incompatible, irreducible, if it is a matter of one and the same thing and under the same respect.’ Therefore it is not possible, ‘it is absolutely impossible that a thing that is moved should be, under the respect that makes it be moved, the mover that moves it.’ To affirm the contrary would be either not to understand what one says or knowingly to deny the principle of contradiction. So that for anyone who understands the true sense of this word, applied to any object whatever: ‘movetur, is moved,’ the conclusion imposes itself of itself and necessarily: ‘therefore by something that is not itself; ergo ab alio.’” In other words, what is moved, having to pass from potency to act, evidently lacks the perfection toward which it tends, and, consequently, has need of someone who gives it this perfection. But the latter can communicate it to it only if he possesses it himself in act. Therefore what moves, that is, what gives the act, is already in act and consequently distinct from what is moved or from what is in potency. Hence this axiom stands out with evidence from the radical distinction, already established in ontology, between potency and act. The second axiom: one cannot proceed to infinity. The second axiom is no less manifest. In a series of essentially subordinated movers, the last acts only because it is moved by the preceding one, and this one by a preceding one; if one must proceed to infinity, one will never come to the end: no first mover, no movement.

One may say as one will that the series suffices for itself; one will not avoid the absurd. Just as each mover is not the first cause of movement, so the whole series cannot be the first cause, as a series of unsupported rings will never constitute the point of support necessary to all. If outside the series of these rings there is no first cause to support them all, none will hold, and likewise, if outside these movers, of which one is moved by another, there is no immovable mover who is the first principle of all movement, there will never be movement in the universe. Since the universe moves, we must conclude to a mover who moves and is not moved, and who is consequently, without admixture of potency, the pure Act, God blessed for ages. A popular form of the argument. There is a popular way of proposing the argument, whose value can escape no one. It is an incontestable principle in modern science that a body at rest cannot give itself movement of itself and that a body in movement cannot of itself modify its movement: the infallible calculations on the traction of locomotives, the marvels of mechanics, rest on this law of inertia. Either, then, one conceives the world at rest from all eternity, and then it is impossible to explain movement if there is not a Mover distinct from the world and himself immovable; or one conceives it in movement, and then it is impossible to explain that the movement should be modified and that there should be in the world those alternations of movement and rest that both science and common sense observe. We must therefore recognize, outside and above the world, a first and immovable Mover who has produced, who moves and rules all things.

The second proof: efficient causes

The second argument is drawn from the activity of creatures and rests on experience, whether internal or external, which shows us in the world a series of dependent causes. It can be summarized thus: We discover in this universe efficient causes of which none is cause of itself (otherwise it would be before itself, which is absurd), but subordinated in such a way that one depends on another, either in its being, as the son depends on the father, or in its operation, as the hammer depends on the hand. Now it is impossible that all efficient causes should depend on other causes in their being and in their operation. One must therefore arrive at a first independent cause, which suffices fully for itself and produces all the others, and which, therefore, is the fullness of perfection, and whom we shall call God. It is manifest that all causes cannot depend on other causes in their being; for, just as the last depends on the intermediate, the latter depends on the preceding one, and so on: therefore, if there is not a first independent cause, there will be neither intermediate cause nor last cause. And likewise for operation: as the last depends on the intermediate, the latter depends on the preceding one, and so on without term. If there is not, then, a first independent cause, there will be no operation. Since we observe operation in the universe, we must conclude to a first cause independent in its being, and therefore unproduced, independent in its operation, and therefore fully sufficient for itself to act. Thus, as the first proof ascends from the series of subordinated movers to a first immovable mover, the second leads from the series of subordinated causes to a first unproduced cause, which is by itself and explains everything. Now such a cause cannot lack any perfection, since it is the source of being: it is the true God, from whom all proceeds and to whom all returns. We see that the principle of causality intervenes in all these arguments to communicate to them its unshakable force.

The third proof: contingency

The third proof rises from the contingent being to the necessary being, and also starts from experience, which discovers around us so many feeble beings, bearing in themselves the manifest characteristics of their insufficiency. We see, then, contingent things, which can be or not be, which do not have in themselves the reason for their existence, which begin by generation and end by corruption or death. Now it is impossible that everything be contingent. Therefore we must admit a necessary being, who is the reason for the being of the others, suffices for himself, is the source of all perfection, the true God. Why not everything can be contingent. Saint Thomas reasons thus to show that everything cannot be contingent: Since the contingent can be or not be, it begins, and therefore there was a moment when it was not. Therefore, if everything is contingent, there was a moment when nothing was. But if nothing was at a given moment, nothing would be today, and since today there are realities, we must admit that not everything is contingent, that there is a necessary being, existing by himself and cause of all the others. In other words, since the contingent is not by itself, it has need of another who communicates being to it. But the latter, in order to communicate a reality to the others, must exist before all the others, and hold his being not from another (otherwise one would have to proceed to infinity, which we have already declared impossible) but from himself. Thus the argument proves not only that there is something necessary in the world, but that there is a necessary being, by himself, source of all being, absolute perfection, pure Act. The objection of the materialists. This is why the old objection of the materialists, taken up in our day by unbelief, falls before the evidence. They reply that if each being taken separately is contingent, the whole series is infinite and necessary. We answer: Since each member of the series is contingent, the whole series is a collection of contingents. Now the contingent added to the contingent makes only the contingent, just as dwarfs added to dwarfs remain dwarfs and never make a complete man. The effect cannot be greater than the cause. The series is an effect of contingents. Therefore it cannot be called necessary, unless one says that the effect is superior to its cause. It follows that the necessary being who makes the contingents exist is distinct from them, superior to them, their reason for being and their cause, and likewise that he bears in himself alone the reason for his existence. But to bear in oneself one’s reason for existing is to be the source of perfection, which depends on no other, which is stopped by no limit, which is without admixture of imperfection or of potency: the pure Act that ontology has already revealed to us, the God of goodness.

The fourth proof: degrees of perfection

The fourth argument is also a posteriori, by the spectacle of creation, and always rests on experience, which shows us in things degrees of perfection, from which we rise to the supremely Perfect. It therefore differs totally from the argument of Saint Anselm, which is a priori and remains in the purely ideal order. It is also distinguished from the three preceding arguments, for it considers not only movement, as the first proof does, nor only operation, as the second proof does, nor only generation and corruption, as the third proof does, but something deeper and more permanent, which belongs to the very order of being, that is, the degrees of perfection. Experience makes us discover in the world things that have more or less being, more or less life, more or less intelligence, etc. Now, where there are such degrees, one must find that which is supremely being, supremely life, supremely intelligence. Therefore there exists someone who is supremely being, supremely life, supremely intelligence, etc. But what is supremely such in a genus is the cause of all the rest in that same genus. Therefore there exists someone who is the cause of everything that has being, of everything that has life, of everything that has intelligence, etc. Now the cause of all being, of all life, of all intelligence, manifestly unites in himself all perfection, is the fullness of being, the pure Act, the true God. Thus the proof concludes from degrees to what is supremely, from multiplicity to what is one and supreme. Justifying the axiom. It is a matter of justifying the axiom quod est maxime tale…: what is supremely such in a genus is cause of all the rest in that genus. The principle is understood of a genus of perfection that admits degrees, and this is why one cannot think of saying: what is supremely man is the cause of all other men; human nature does not admit more or less within the species, all individuals being in the same specific degree. It is likewise understood of perfections that do not include limit and lack in their concept, and in which, consequently, one can conceive the supremely perfect, and not of mixed perfections. Since there is no subsistent whiteness, it would be absurd to say: what is supremely white is the cause of everything that is white. The sense of the axiom is therefore this: what is supremely subsistent is the cause of everything that subsists, what is supremely living is the cause of everything that lives, what is supremely intelligent, wise, good, is the cause of everything that is intelligent, wise, good. Here is why. In a genus that admits degrees, whoever is not or does not have the perfection supremely, but something diminished, does not possess this perfection by virtue of his nature. What belongs by nature belongs integrally, without diminution; and since nature does not entail more or less, what belongs to nature is not more in one and less in another. Therefore the things that have the perfection more or less and in restricted degrees must receive it from another as from their source. But this cause itself must be, in the last analysis, what has the perfection by its own nature, that to which the perfection belongs without diminution, without measure, in the supreme degree, that is, what is supremely such. Whence the demonstration of our axiom: what is supremely such in a genus is the cause of all the rest in that genus. Here again it is the principle of causality that sustains the whole argument. We are thus led, by the degrees of being, to the Cause, source of all beauty, fullness of all perfection, ideal and reality that must ravish all love.

The fifth proof: the order of the universe

The fifth proof completes and crowns the fourth, which has just shown us an ordered multiplicity in these degrees all ending in the supremely Perfect. One rises from order to a first ordainer, to a first Intelligence, to a first Wisdom, distinct from the world, superior to the world, and whom we call God. The argument is always a posteriori, from what we observe in the universe; it is called cosmological because it is drawn from the organization of the world. We discover in nature a particular order, that is, the inclination or tendency of each thing toward its proper end, and a universal order, that is, the admirable harmony of all things conspiring toward a common end. Each of these two orders furnishes the irrefutable proof that there exists a supreme ordainer, all-powerful and all-perfect.

  • The inorganic world. We have noticed an internal tendency, which maintains each being in unity according to a determinate type, to the point that science must count so many species of simple bodies, so many species of compound bodies, with permanent and irreducible properties.

  • Plants. This living force, still more evident, governs all the parts for the good of the whole, ensures nutrition, development, the multiplication of cells, the fecundation of the seed, the perpetuity of the species.

  • Animals. The tendency is so manifest, the solidarity of the various parts so certain, that the study of a single tooth sufficed Cuvier, as we have said, to reconstruct in his mind the whole organism. The marvels of instinct, observed so many times, made the celebrated entomologist H. Fabre say that he saw God in insects.

  • The human body. Order is above all admirable in the masterpiece that is the human body, whether in the structure of the organs, in the nervous system and the system of the great sympathetic, or in the double circulation: the globules of the blood, placed one after another, would go several times around the earth, and yet all play their role so well in the organism that the blood grows poor to the extent that the red globules are lacking, and that the white globules rush, like skirmishers, to the threatened points, to defend them against the invasion of microbes.

  • The whole world. Finally, in the whole ensemble of the world, we discover a universal order, which sings, like the heavens, the divine glory: the dynamic order, or of causality, by which bodies act upon one another according to their mass or their distance, as in universal attraction; the teleological order, or of finality, according to which minerals serve plants, plants serve animals, animals serve man. The harmony of the infinitely great and the infinitely small is understood by all:

“Phrase so profound That one sounds it in vain: The eye sees a world in it, The soul finds a God in it.” (Victor Hugo.)

Blind chance. How could blind chance make this book that is the universe? Let us recall a manifest demonstration, within reach of all and confirmed by the calculus of probabilities: “Suppose that you find ten letters forming the word ABSOLUMENT. Here you no longer hesitate and you affirm, without fear of error, that the author of this juxtaposition knew how to read and wished to form the French word that you read. While recognizing that the contrary is theoretically possible, you will not regard it as practically realizable. And, in fact, in this case, the calculation shows that there are 3,628,800 to bet against 1 in favor of your conclusion… One sees that it sufficed to increase a little the number of letters forming the remarkable arrangement, in order to pass from an ordinary probability to a practical certainty.” If it is a matter not of a phrase but of a whole book, of an exquisite poem, like the Iliad, the Aeneid, the Divine Comedy, the certitude is absolute and unshakable: although the combinations of letters that form these masterpieces are always theoretically possible and can always be realized, it is certain that they will never be realized without the action of an intelligent cause. Is the order of the immense universe not more complicated than the arrangement of letters in a volume? If the poem proves the poet, if the clock proves the clockmaker, the order of the world proves a separate Intelligence, endowed with an infinite wisdom to conceive it, and with an infinite power to realize it. Conclusion of the five ways. Here is how the five Thomistic ways lead us to the first Mover, the first Agent, the first Necessary, the first and sovereign Being, the first and supreme Ordainer and Governor, Source of all that is, Good of all good, and whose vision will one day be our supreme Felicity.


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
On distinctions

General intro. This is a short paper by Havoc regarding the various distinctions in the various scholastic schools and which the Thomists hold, what they dont and why. This paper will cover the defini

 
 
 
On Being

General Intro This is a short paper by Havoc to aid in knowing the doctrine of Being and its universality + application in all subjects. A false notion in this doctrine leads one to errors in basicall

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

Socials​
If you are above the age of 18 and are catholic with a decent level of knowledge feel free to join the server! 

  • Discord
  • Instagram
  • X
  • TikTok
  • Youtube
bottom of page