On Being
General Intro
This is a short paper by Havoc to aid in knowing the doctrine of Being and its universality + application in all subjects. A false notion in this doctrine leads one to errors in basically all other topics. This topic will be broken down into all its parts and covered individually in later articles on both this site and on the substack. https://substack.com/@catholichavoc
Purpose + Nature of metaphysics
I think it’d be vital to first define philosophy as a science of first causes before getting into the topic to further help in understanding the nature of metaphysics and how it’s distinct from the other sciences. Now philosophy is the systematic study of things through their 1st causes & principles by using the natural powers of human reason. This differs from Sacred Theology which takes divine revelation as its initial point & considers truths made known through faith. The philosophy of nature studies material things insofar as they’re subject to motion & change, whilst Logic (rational philosophy) studies the structure of reasoning, concepts, propositions, etc. Metaphysics on the other hand belongs to the field of speculative philosophy which examines being in its broadest + most universal sense. For the scholastics the core object of metaphysics is being as being. Whereas the specific sciences limit their examinations to particular aspects of reality (v.g. Math → studying quantity, physics → studying the natural world in terms of motion & change). Metaphysics considers reality without limiting itself to any particular category of beings. It concerns itself with the most fundamental of principles and causes that considers everything that exists. Metaphysical investigation depends on the entire order of reality, from inanimate objects & living organisms to humans & God. All these distinct realities are considered in terms of their common object (being), although they possess existence in a fundamentally different manner. Hence metaphysics seeks to comprehend individual things and the universal principles that make their existence intelligible. The Thomists regard metaphysics as wisdom in the strictest sense. Although other sciences can exercise a particular form of wisdom within their respective fields by studying + defending the principles on which they depend; metaphysics takes up a distinctive position since it investigates the most universal principles of knowledge and reality. People tend to confuse the “task” of metaphysics by positing that its simply to accumulate information about that which exists (existing objects). Instead it [metaphysics] examines the foundations upon which other forms of knowledge rests on + considers if their underlying principles can be justified. This is why we say “everything leads back to metaphysics” as its the foundation of all things, yet logic is to be studied prior to metaphysics as without proper rational phil. one can easily err in all other fields. The metaphysics of the realists also challenges the skepticists by defending the possibility of genuine knowledge of reality. They maintain that human reason when adequately exercised can attain objective truths about what exists. Via the examination of the first principles, metaphysics looks to establish a rational foundation for understanding the world and the conditions under which knowledge of said world is possible.
Concept + analogy of being
Being is the most basic concept available to our intellect. Every other concept presupposes some understanding of what it means for something to be. Prior to the intellect being able to distinguish between different kinds of things, it first needs to apprehend them as existing as possessing some form of reality. This particular understanding involves the process of abstraction, through which the mind considers the intelligible nature of a thing distinct from the particular situation in which its encountered. Ergo a distinction must be made between intuitive / direct cognition of a particular object vs abstract concept via which the intellect comprehends a nature in a universal manner. Being can’t be classified as a genus in the same way as concepts (v.g. Animal, plant). A genus extends to a particular range of things, whereas being extends across every category of reality. There’s nothing in existence that falls outside of being and it is for this reason that being is described as a transcendental: transcends the limitations and classifications and applies in various ways to everything that’s real. Being’s universality raises a question amongst the schools, [if the term “being” applies both to God and creatures/created things then does it signify the same reality in each case or does it possess a different meaning dependent on its subject]. The Thomists answer this problem by applying the doctrine of analogy (crdl. Cajetan has the best treatise on this). We distinguish that terms are understood in 3 modes of signification 1. Univocal: term has the same meaning when applied to different subjects 2. Equivocal: the same word/term expresses different meanings 3. Analogical: a term is applied to different subjects according to meanings that are related to one another although they arent totally identical. Cajetan describes the analogy of being as important for its capacity to describe the relation between God and creatures. According to Thomist metaphysics God and created beings aren’t beings in the same manner per se, yet neither are their modes of being so unrelated to the point where the knowledge of God becomes impossible. 2 forms of analogy will be discussed here: 1. Analogy of attribution: the term is applied to several things because of their relation to one subject (cajetan calls this the primum analogatum). The term is attributed primarily to that subject and secondarily to others because of their connection 2. Analogy of proper proportionality: a perfection can be present in different subjects according to the distinctive mode of each. For example, in the case of being, God exists through Himself, while creatures possess existence in a received + dependent manner. Ergo the reality of being is affirmed of both yet not according to an identical mode. The analogy of proper proportionality maintains the intelligibility of the relation between God and creatures & the difference that’s fundamental between them. This isnt to confuse by positing that God is one being amongst trillions of others, created beings don’t possess existence independently of their first cause. The doctrine on analogy looks for to solve 2 issues; (1). When being is treated univocally; (2). When being is treated equivocally. The issue with the first problem is if God & creatures had being in the exact same sense and manner, then there’s virtually no distinction between the finite and infinite. Such a line of reasoning breaks down the distinction between God and the created order which essentially just leads to pantheism. The issue with the second problem is if the word being has entirely different meanings when employed to God & creatures, then human reasoning would lack a significant conceptual foundation for moving from the knowledge of created things to knowledge of their first cause. This position leads to issues in natural theology and is capable of leading to skepticism regarding the possibility of knowing God. The doctrine of analogy supplies a substitute by asserting that the meanings of being are all truly related without having to be identical. So it maintains the transcendence of God and the possibility of rational questioning into the relation of God and creation. Within the domain of metaphysics, a transcendental property is categorized as a characteristic that extends throughout the entire realm of being. Now unlike an ordinary property that only belongs to a particular class of things a transcendental property extends to all that exists, but it expresses being under a distinct conceptual perspective.
Transcendental properties of being
A transcendental property is categorized as a characteristic that extends throughout the entire realm of being. Now, unlike an ordinary property that only belongs to a particular class of things, a transcendental property extends to all that exists, but it expresses being under a distinct conceptual perspective. These properties don’t introduce new substances into reality; instead, they help in forming adequate proportions for being which aids the intellect in conceptualizing it even though they arent separate from being itself in the way that one physical object is separate from another. This distinction is referred to as the distinction of reason. Consequently, the transcendentals are said to be changeable with being. Each applies universally to that which exists whilst expressing a different way of understanding that reality. There are 6 principal transcendental properties:
1. Thing (res): considers being in relation to its essence / quidditas, that is, what a thing is fundamentally. To consider something as a thing is to consider its intelligible identity instead of solely its existence in an indistinguishable way.
2. One: expresses being insofar as its undivided in itself. Something is one to the extent that it has a particular integrity / internal unity, this distinguishes it from a plurality of different things. Now unity doesn't mean physical indivisibility; instead, it indicates that a being is understood as a sole entity according to the relevant mode of its particular existence.
3. Something: expresses the distinctness of a being from other beings. Something isnt an indistinguishable part of reality but contains an identity by which it can be distinguished from what it isnt. In short this principle helps to distinguish a being from other beings by identifying what it isnt.
4. True: concerns the relation between being and intellect. We know that a thing is intelligible insofar as it’s able to be known, whilst truth involves the conformity between “what is” and what the intellect comprehends. In our judgement this relation becomes clear when the intellect affirms something is as it is. Hence truth doesnt depend on a person’s experience instead the possibility of true judgement depends on the intelligibility of reality + capacity of the intellect to comprehend it.
5. Good: considers being in relation to appetite or desire, in its broadest comprehension its the tendency of a being toward what fulfills its nature. Everything is good insofar as it has being and the perfections appropriate to its nature. Ergo goodness isnt restricted to moral conduct since it also concerns the fulfillment & perfection of things generally. Now this doesnt mean that every action / condition is morally good, but the metaphysical claim is simply that being (considered as it possesses actuality & perfection) is desirable in an appropriate sense.
6. Beauty: associated with the indication of intelligible order & perfection in a being. It’s classically described in relation to the magnificence of truth even though beauty isn't reducible to truth alone. A beautiful thing has form, proportion, integrity, or proportion that contribute to its understanding as pleasing in contemplation. Hence beauty concerns the objective characteristics of what’s perceived & the intellectual / sensory understanding by which those characteristics are understood. In the thomist structure, beauty belongs to the broader account of being since it conveys a mode in which the perfection + intelligibility of reality become manifest. After taking all these transcendentals together, they reveal that being can be considered under various linked aspects. Unity concerns
First principles of being
Metaphysics examines that which exists and the fundamental principles by which reality + reasoning become intelligible. These principles supply the basis for logical thought & guide the interpretation of the real world (although this is done in various ways).
Principle of Non Contradiction
The law of non-contradiction (LNC) holds that something can’t both be and not be in the same time and in the same respect. It’s viewed as one of the most foundational principles of metaphysics since any consistent affirmation or negation presupposes that contradictory claims cant be true in the same sense. For example, a proposition asserting that a particular object has a given characteristic can’t be affirmed and denied simultaneously under identical conditions without contradiction. Ergo the principle lays down the foundational requirement for serious judgement and dialogue.
Principle of identity
This principle conveys the idea that a thing is identical with itself. In its most basic articulation, being = what it is. Furthermore, this principle mirrors the intelligibility & determinancy of reality: a thing must have some identity by which it can be distinguished + understood. Within metaphysical examination, identity also furnishes a foundation for recognizing things as the same entities across different acts of thought, descriptions, or circumstances granted that the pertinent conditions of identity are met.
Principle of Excluded middle
This principle holds that for a definite proposition & its negation one or the other must hold. There isnt a 3rd possibility between the affirmation and negation of the proposition, granted that the proposition is sufficiently determinate & the relevant terms are used consistently. Paired with the LNC this principle aids in establishing the foundational structure of classical logical reasoning. The 2 principles (LNC & LEM) are related yet distinct; LNC excludes both the truth of a proposition + its negation. LEM excludes an intermediate truth value between them in classical logic.
Principle of sufficient reason
The PSR holds that reason holds that what exists / occurs needs to have a sufficient explanation. Contingent beings don't contain in their own essence a sufficient explanation for the fact that they exist. Hence their existence requires an explanation in terms of causes / other grounds beyond themselves. This principle is important in arguments that pertain to the existence of God. God is understood as a subsistent being itself (impsum esse subsistens) instead of a contingent being whose existence needs to be received from another entity.
Principle of Finality
This principle is expressed in the maxim every agent acts for an end. Now according to this principle actions & natural processes are intelligible in relation to the ends toward which they’re directed. Now in the case of humans, these ends can include consciously chosen goals and in natural processes finality doesnt need to imply conscious deliberation. The philosophy of the thomists sees final causality as an absolutely necessary aspect of the explanation of change & action. In the view that something contemplates only what generates the process whilst totally neglecting the end / outcome toward which its directed is a report of an account that’s incomplete. Now chance doesnt contradict finality (this will be covered in a whole different paper regarding chance / luck). Rather chance is perceived as an accidental cause emerging in a manner that wasnt intended by the relevant agents. A chance occurrence can emerge in an intelligible order of causal activity and within the Thomist account the existence of chance doesn’t remove the role of final causes in nature.
Fundamental divisions of created being
In this section I will be covering (1). Act potency, (2). Essence & existence, and lastly (3). Substance & accidents.
Act & potency
This can be argued to be possibly one of the core distinctions in Thomistic metaphysics. Act denotes actuality, or the realization of a perfection; potency denotes a capacity to receive / attain such actuality. This distinction permits metaphysics to explain how beings can experience change while remaining intelligible as subjects of that change. A thing thats potentially a specific way has the capacity for a perfection it doesnt have yet. Once that capacity is realized, then the thing is actual in the appropriate respect. An example to help clarify: a material object thats capable of being heated is potentially hot prior to the relevant change and is actually hot once that capacity has been actualized / realized. There are 5 theses by which the act-potency relation is expressed: 1. Priority in definition: Act is prior to potency in the order of explanation since a potency can be understood solely in relation to the actuality its capable of receiving 2. Priority in the actualization of potency: a potency is brought into actuality by something thats already in the relevant respect. A simple potential condition cant account for its own actualization if considered solely as potential. 3. Priority in perfection: act is more perfect than potency insofar as act represents the fulfillment of a capacity instead of its unrealized possibility. 4. Intelligibility via actuality: potency is perceived by reference to the act to which its ordered. The ability to become something is intelligible in its relation to the corresponding realized state. 5. Limitation by potency: an act received in a potency is limited according to the capacity + mode of the recipient. Hence the perfection is received (not necessarily possessed) in an unrestricted manner. These theses supply a general structure for explaining change, limitation, and the grades of perfection that are found amongst created beings. The theses also paves the way for the distinctions between finite beings (involves potentiality) and God who’s understood as pure act.
Essence-existence
Essence that refers to what a thing is, existence refers to the act by which that thing actually is. Finite beings possess a real distinction between these principles: understanding the essence of a thing doesnt by itself establish that the thing exists. For instance: someone can understand what a particular kind of being would be without consequently establishing that such a being exists in reality. The essence makes the thing intelligible as a determinate sort of thing, whilst existence explains for its actuality. In created things, essence operates as the principle that receives & limits the act of existence. Their existence therefore is contingent instead of something that follows necessarily from what they are. They have being without being the ultimate source of their own existence, and their actuality is consequently understood in relation to a cause. On the other hand, God is described (in thomistic phil.) as subsistent being itself. In God essence & existence arent distinct principles composed together. God is understood as the unrestricted act of being that has no received existence + depending on no cause outside Himself. This distinction is essential for the thomists since it accounts for the relation between God and man / creation. Created beings have existence in a limited + dependent manner whilst God is the ultimate source of the act of existence itself.
Substance & accidents
Substance is that which exists in itself instead of inhering in another subject. It’s the underlying subject of properties & changes, and its associated with the notion of an individual subsisting being. Accidents exist in a subject rather than independently. They describe / alter a substance without ordinarily constituting separate substances in their own right. Among the traditional categories of accidents, quality & relation have specific importance. Quality relates to an accidental determination that affects the character, condition, capacity, or operation of a subject. Habits, dispositions and powers can be considered under this category. A quality can explain why a substance acts / behaves in a particular way without being identical to the substance itself. Relation conveys the reference of one thing toward another. Now unlike a quality considered solely in itself, a relation involves an intelligible connection between related terms. Ergo, its evaluation includes a subject in which the relation exists, a term towards which its directed, and a foundation that accounts for the relation.
Hierarchy of Being
This section will be covering 2 particular topics; (1). The metaphysical structure of reality, (2). The continuing significance of thomistic metaphysics.
Metaphysical structure of reality
All the principles that were discussed earlier leads to an account of reality thats organized around the distinction between finite / composite beings & the simplity of God. Created beings are described by a mix of act and potency, essence and existence, substance and existence. These 3 distinctions explain how finite things can have determinate forms of actuality whilst staying limited, changeable and dependent upon causes. God is understood differently (explained a few times earlier). He’s pure act meaning that He possesses no unrealized potency and isnt composed of essence and existence as distinct principles. Hence divine being is understood as unrestricted and independent compared to the received and limited existence of created things. This examination establishes the conception of a hierarchy of being. This hierarchy doesnt classify things according to their particular dimension (size), complexity nor its practical importance. It concerns their modes of actuality, degree of perfection, and the extent to which their existence depends on another. God = foundational position in this order as the first cause + ultimate source of all being.
Continuing significance of Thomistic Metaphysics
The importance of thomistic metaphysics in the contemporary world rests in its attempt to provide a coherent account of existence, knowledge, causality, and the relation between finite reality & its supreme grounding. The thomists hold that a refreshed engagement with these principles can contribute to a better understanding of human reasoning, moral life, and all the intellectual foundations of culture. Now from this perspective metaphysics isnt some “abstract exercise” that’s detached from ordinary experience. Instead it addresses the fundamental questions regarding what exists, how things can be known, and if reality has an intelligible structure that human reason can study. The thomists present metaphysics as a resource for examining the philosophical foundations of contemporary thought. Its emphasis on objective reality, rational examination, & distinction between finite and infinite being and offers a thorough framework for responding to skepticism and intellectual disintegration.

Comments