top of page

On Hylomorphism

Oct 24
5 min read

General intro.

This is a short paper made by Havoc made to help everyone understand easily the doctrine of Hylomorphism and how its the bulwark of the philosophia perennis. We all know the modern age is filled with slop perverse opinions, so it’d be crucial to have a restoration of proper classical thought since its a prerequisite for both scientific progress and ontological sanity. Now to reject hylomorphic composition is to precipitate the collapse of the intelligible order; for if there isnt any stable subject underlying substantial transformation then the physical world dissolves into an irrational flux where knowledge is impossible and nihilism becomes inevitable.

Etymologically derived from the greek word hyle (matter) and morphe (form), hylomorphism is the doctrine that every physical substance is a substantial compound (compositum) of 2 intrinsic, constitutive principles: prime matter and substantial form. This synthesis provides the only rigorous solutions to the fundamental problem of natural philosophy, mediating between the heraclitean error of universal flux (denies stability by asserting that all is becoming) and the parmenidean error of immobilism (denis the reality of change by asserting it is merely apparent). The moderate realist (aristotelian / thomistic) synthesis solves this antinomy by distinguishing between the principles of becoming and the principles of being:

  1. Principles of generation (in fieri):

  2. Subject: that which persists through the transformation

  3. Form: the terminus ad quem or the actuality acquired

  4. Privation: the lack of a form in a subject capable of possessing it (a principle per accidens)

  5. Principles of composition (in facto esse)

  6. Prime matter: the purely passive, indeterminate substantial principle

  7. Substantial form: the active, determining principle that specifies the essence

Prime matter

The necessity of prima matter comes forth from the undeniable reality of substantial transformation, wherein one substance ceases to be and another emerges. Unlike the crude atoms of the mechanists (which merely undergo local motion or accidental rearrangement) substantial change requires a subject that is entirely devoid of its own act. Prime matter is the first, intrinsic, and substantial subject, defined by Aristotle’s negative formula: “nec est quid, nec quale, nec quantum, nec aliquid eorum quibus ens determinatur” (its neither a ‘what’, nor a quality, nor a quantity, nor any of the things by which being is determined). It is nearly nothing yet its not nothing; its the real capacity for being.

In defense of the proper status of Prime matter as pure potency we shall refute the erroneous propositions of suarez, durandus, and henry of ghent who all attribute to matter a certain entitative act or independent existence, the thomist position maintains that matter possesses no existence of its own. If matter had its own act of existing independent of form, the union of matter and form would be merely accidental, resulting in a heap of entities rather than a true substance. Such partial existence is a contradiction in metaphysics; that which is in potency cant simultaneously be in act under the same respect. Matter is only produced through concreation (it doesnt precede form in time but is created together with it by God within the compositum).

These are the 3 metaphysical properties of prime matter:

  1. Passivity & incorruptibility: As the subject premium, its ungenerable and incorruptible; it can only begin to be through the creative act of God.

  2. Innate appetite: matter possesses a natural inclination toward form (a drive for actuality that finds its highest terrestrial perfection in the human soul).

  3. Unintelligibility: since all intelligibility follows actuality, and Prime Matter is pure potency, its in itself unintelligible. Its known only per analogy to the form it sustains.

The existence of Prime Matter is demonstrated by the reality of substantial change (generation & corruption) and the numerical multiplication of individuals within a species. Its matter signed by quantity that allows the specific nature of man to be individuated in Peter and Paul. From this radical potentiality, we turn to the principle of specification.

Substantial form: the principle of actuality & specification

If matter is the principle of potentiality, Substantial form is the principle of actuality. Its defined as the primus actus materiae primae (the first act which gives substantial being to the matter). While we treat “substantial form” as second intention in the order of Logic (a mental construct), it has a firm foundation in reality as the ontological core of the substance. Following is the 3fold metaphysical role of form:

  1. Specification: it constitutes the species, determining the whatness of the thing

  2. Being: its the principle through which the compositum participates in the act of existing

  3. Operation: following the maxim action follows being, the form determines the proper operations and powers of the substance

Here’s a small chart I had ai generate to help visualize

The absolute unity of substantial form must be asserted. The divine doctor demonstrates that in a single individual, there is but one substantial form which provides all perfections. Using the analogy of numbers, we see that just as adding or subtracting a unit changes the species of a number, adding a second substantial form would render the first accidental. Pluralism which is the error of scotus and bonaventure destroys the substantial unity of the person, reducing human beings to a mere accidental heap of forms.

The unio hylomorphica: the substantial compound

The immediate union of matter and form isthe only safeguard for the unity of the individual. This isnt a mechanical assembly but a substantial union. Now within this union there exists a real distinction: matter isnt form, and form isnt matter. The thomists recognize a double potency and double act within the substance:

  1. Order of essence: matter (potency) is united to form (act)

  2. Order of existence: the essence (matter / form compound) stands as potency to the act of existence

The real distinction between essence and existence in all created mobile beings is the definitive proof of their contingency. Because their nature is distinct from their existence they dont exist by necessity. They’re dependent on the actus purus (God). Without this distinction we fall into the grave error of pantheism or worse (nihilism).

Refutation of the non thomistic positions

  1. Mechanism & pure atomism (Descartes, gassendi): these systems reduce substantial change to mere local motion, ignoring the ratio ens. By denying substantial form, they end up destroy qualitative reality and teleology, consequently reducing the universe to some blind machine.

  2. Dynamism & monadology (Leibniz): By positing unextended force as the root of reality to have an accident (force) without a subject. Unextended points cant constitute extended bodies; its a mathematical abstraction, not a physical reality.

  3. Pluralism of substantial forms (Scotus & Bonaventure): if a form of corporeity gives substantial being first, the soul can only be an accident. This renders the individual a composite heap and destroys the ontological unity of the human person.

  4. Suarist errors: By granting matter an entitative act independent of form, Suarez violates the principle of contradiction (LNC). If matter is act, its no longer potency; if its not potency, substantial change is impossible.

  5. Dialectical materialism (Marx, Engels): Marx makes the mistake of conflating privation (negation of form) for a struggle of opposites. Using Fr. Greniers distinction between opposition and negation we can see that change isnt a war of contradictions but the fulfillment of a capacity by an act.

The Thomist maxims of Hylomorphism

  1. The corruption of one form is the generation of another

  2. Form gives being; its the principle of existence and specification

  3. Action follows being; the operations of a thing reveal its nature

  4. Matter exists for the sake of form; the potential exists for the actual

Scholastic Summary

Here’s another summary I made using ai


Here's my paper in pdf format.


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
On distinctions

General intro. This is a short paper by Havoc regarding the various distinctions in the various scholastic schools and which the Thomists hold, what they dont and why. This paper will cover the defini

 
 
 
On Being

General Intro This is a short paper by Havoc to aid in knowing the doctrine of Being and its universality + application in all subjects. A false notion in this doctrine leads one to errors in basicall

 
 
 
Fr. Hugon on the 5 ways

The five proofs These arguments are of universal scope and hold for all the beings that we discover in this world, inorganic or organic, plants, animals, men and angels. The first proof is drawn from

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

Socials​
If you are above the age of 18 and are catholic with a decent level of knowledge feel free to join the server! 

  • Discord
  • Instagram
  • X
  • TikTok
  • Youtube
bottom of page